Sage Wealth Planning
← All insights

Retirement

Teachers: Don't Be Fooled by the "Tax-Sheltered Annuity" Account

June 2, 2020

The primary retirement account type for employees of non-profit organizations, including schools, libraries, and hospitals, is called a 403(b). The 403(b) structure is what provides the tax deferral of contributions under the Cash or Deferred Arrangement rules. For those who work in businesses, the 401(k) structure is the equivalent type of account.

It has been nearly 50 years since the 403(b) was born, and early on "annuities" — contracts issued by insurance companies — were the only available investment option. A lot has changed over the past five decades, including the investment options available in 403(b) accounts, but the account is still quite often referred to as a tax-sheltered annuity, or TSA.

How to tell whether you own an annuity

How do you know whether you are investing directly into mutual funds or accessing them through "sub-accounts" in an annuity?

  1. If the company you are investing through is an insurance company, there is a good chance it is an annuity structure.
  2. Check whether you own "shares" or "units." If it is the latter, it is definitely an annuity.
  3. Look for the words "contract" and "surrender charge." These are telltale signs you are in an annuity contract.

Why it matters

In a word: cost. Annuities generally cost more than mutual funds. There may be features an individual is specifically seeking, such as a guaranteed death benefit, but most often people are simply not aware of the differences, or of the fees they are paying.

When saving for long-term goals like retirement, fees really matter. Familiarize yourself with your retirement plan options, ask questions, and stay informed.

Questions people ask

Is a 403(b) the same as an annuity?
No. The 403(b) is the account type; an annuity is one kind of investment that can sit inside it. Early 403(b)s offered only annuities, which is why the account is still often called a tax-sheltered annuity, but many plans now offer mutual funds directly.
How do I know if my 403(b) is invested in an annuity?
Three signs: the provider is an insurance company, your statement shows units rather than shares, and the paperwork uses the words contract or surrender charge.
Why do annuity-based 403(b)s cost more?
Annuities generally carry higher fees than mutual funds, sometimes in exchange for insurance features such as a guaranteed death benefit. Over decades of retirement saving, that fee difference compounds.

See whether we're a fit

A free one-hour discovery call to hear what you're weighing and tell you plainly whether we can help. No preparation needed, and no obligation.